Great experiences get talked about. Mediocre ones get forgotten.

The pitfalls of relying solely on online reviews as your only source of customer experience feedback.

Online reviews play a pivotal role in shaping a business’s reputation. A glowing review can bring in a new wave of customers, while a poor review can drive them away. As a result, many operators focus heavily on managing online reviews as part of their customer experience strategy.

But here’s the truth: online reviews are just one part of the puzzle. They have limitations, and relying solely on them to gauge your overall customer experience can leave a lot of valuable insights on the table.

The Role of Online Reviews in Customer Experience

When customers have an outstanding experience, they’re more likely to share their thoughts online. Great experiences get talked about—whether it’s via a glowing review on Google, TripAdvisor, or a post on social media. Positive reviews can be powerful marketing tools that not only attract new customers but also validate your service and build trust. However, it’s important to understand that online reviews only tell part of the story. They represent a small fraction of your total customer base and can be heavily skewed by a variety of factors.

The “Silence Factor”: Are You Missing the Bigger Picture?

The “silence factor” refers to the discrepancy between the number of customers you serve and the amount of feedback or reviews you receive. For example, if you operate a popular visitor activity and serve thousands of customers each year, but only receive a handful of reviews, it’s clear that most of your customers are not speaking up. This means that you may be missing out on valuable insights from a large portion of your guest base.

There are a few reasons why this happens:

• Not all customers are motivated to leave feedback: Only a small percentage of people who have an average experience will take the time to write a review. Most customers, especially those who have a neutral or mediocre experience, don’t feel compelled to share their thoughts.
• Negative experiences can more often prompt reviews: It’s natural for people to leave feedback when they are dissatisfied, but positive or neutral experiences may go unnoticed unless the customer is particularly enthusiastic.
• Bias in the review sample: The reviews you receive may be skewed based on the emotional highs and lows of your visitors. You might hear from excited thrill-seekers who had a fantastic time or upset customers who faced issues during their visit. But the voices of those who had a “fine” experience—usually the majority—are often silent.

The Limitations of Relying on Online Reviews

While online reviews are helpful, they don’t offer a complete picture of your customer experience. They are often:

• Limited in scope: Online reviews typically focus on one aspect of the experience (e.g., staff friendliness, activity quality, etc.) and lack a detailed analysis of the wider customer journey.
• Subjective: Each reviewer has their own perspective, and the review may not reflect the experiences of the broader customer base.
• Infrequent: Only a small percentage of your customers will leave feedback publicly, meaning that the reviews you see don’t necessarily represent the majority of your clientele.

A More Robust Approach: Consider a Research-Backed Survey Platform

If you want to get a fuller, more accurate understanding of your customer experience, relying on online reviews alone isn’t enough. Instead, consider implementing a survey-based solution that allows you to gather consistent, timely, and thorough feedback through multiple channels. Results can be collected via multiple touch points i.e. , through a feedback link in existing post-experience emails, through kiosks or QR codes onsite or from collecting contact details and prompting a specific email invitation to provide feedback, making it easier to reach all of your customers, including those who are not inclined to leave public reviews. Here’s why this is a smarter approach:

• Consistency: Regularly gathering feedback through surveys ensures that you’re getting insights continuously—not just sporadic reviews. It helps you track trends over time and understand how your customer experience is evolving. Critically, it also allows you to intervene quickly if something changes.
• Timeliness: Surveys are best triggered within a few days after the experience has concluded , ensuring that you capture feedback while the experience is still fresh in their minds while also giving people a little time to reflect. This gives you more relevant and accurate data than self-prompted online reviews, which may be written long after the visit.
• Wider Reach: By offering more survey options, such as through post experience emails, in-person kiosks or self-entry QR codes, you can gather feedback from customers who may not be  inclined to leave an online review. This widens your feedback base and will also ensure that you’re talking with a true representation of your customers, giving you inclusive insights that you can have confidence in.
• Quality: By having a well-designed and considered customer experience research programme, the insights you can draw from it will be representative and inclusive meaning the information you’re making business decisions based on is accurate and reliable.

By using a research-backed survey platform with multiple collection method options, you can gather comprehensive data that offers actionable insights, giving you the information you need to fine-tune your offerings. Whether it’s improving staff interactions, adjusting the flow of the activity, or enhancing facilities, a well-rounded feedback strategy will help you make informed decisions that benefit both your business and your customers.

While online reviews are valuable, they shouldn’t be the sole source of feedback. They provide a limited view of your customer experience, and relying on them alone can lead to missed opportunities for improvement. By embracing a more robust solution like a survey platform from a reputable provider, you can gather consistent, timely, and actionable insights that truly reflect the voice of your customers. This will allow you to elevate your visitor experience.

Loved this article? Every month we shine a light on the best experience operators and industry updates to bring you our monthly edition of “Inside Out – The Experience eZine”.
SUBSCRIBE HERE